YOU SAID:
Your first wasn't Jojo, it was me, Dio!
INTO JAPANESE
あなたの最初はジョジョじゃなかった、それは私だった、ディオ!
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Your first time was not JoJo, that was me, Dio!
INTO JAPANESE
あなたの初めてのジョージョー、私は、ディオではなかった!
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Your first Joe Joe, I was not Dio!
INTO JAPANESE
あなたの最初のジョージョー、私はディオではなかった!
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Your first Joe Joe, I was not Dio!
That didn't even make that much sense in English.