YOU SAID:
You and me, we got big reputations.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたと私、私たちは大きな評判を得ました。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
You and I, we had a great reputation.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたと私は評判が良かった。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
You and I were popular.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたと私は人気者でした。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
You and I were popular.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.