YOU SAID:
you? a homosexual? why ever did you do that?
INTO JAPANESE
あなた?同性愛者?なぜあなたはそれをしたのですか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
you? homosexual? why did you do that
INTO JAPANESE
あなた?同性愛者?どうしてそんなことをしました
BACK INTO ENGLISH
you? homosexual? why did you do that
That didn't even make that much sense in English.