YOU SAID:
Why the heck does my pinky toe hurt?
INTO JAPANESE
なぜ私の小指が痛いの?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why does my little finger hurt?
INTO JAPANESE
小指が痛いのはなぜですか。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why do my little fingers hurt?
INTO JAPANESE
なぜ小指が痛いの?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why do my little fingers hurt?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.