YOU SAID:
why is a cat over there even though its supposed to be here?
INTO JAPANESE
ここにいるはずなのに、なぜあそこに猫がいるの?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why is there a cat over there when I should be here?
INTO JAPANESE
私がここにいるべきなのに、なぜあそこに猫がいるのですか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Why is there a cat over there when I should be here?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.