YOU SAID:
What if this X person was the killer?
INTO JAPANESE
この X 人が何キラーか。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
This X-men where killer.
INTO JAPANESE
この X-メンがキラー。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
X-men is a killer.
INTO JAPANESE
X-メンはキラーです。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
X-men is a killer.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.