YOU SAID:
They weren't kidding when they called me Well, a witch
INTO JAPANESE
彼らは私に電話したときに冗談ではありませんでした、まあ、魔女
BACK INTO ENGLISH
They weren't joking when I called me, well, witch
INTO JAPANESE
魔女に電話しても冗談じゃなかった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Calling the witch was not a joke
INTO JAPANESE
魔女を呼ぶことは冗談ではありませんでした
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Calling a witch was not a joke
INTO JAPANESE
魔女を呼ぶことは冗談ではありませんでした
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Calling a witch was not a joke
That didn't even make that much sense in English.