YOU SAID:
The wolf hit the frog with a bat
INTO JAPANESE
オオカミはコウモリでカエルを殴った
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The wolf beat the frog with a bat
INTO JAPANESE
オオカミはカエルをコウモリで打った
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The wolf struck the frog with a bat
INTO JAPANESE
オオカミはカエルにコウモリを打った
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The wolf struck the frog with a bat
That didn't even make that much sense in English.