YOU SAID:

The cat was very tasty tonight in the pool.

INTO JAPANESE

猫は今夜プールでとても美味しかった。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

The cat was very good in the pool tonight.

INTO JAPANESE

猫は今夜プールでとても良かった。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

The cat was very good at the pool tonight.

INTO JAPANESE

猫は今夜プールでとても上手でした。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

The cat was very good at the pool tonight.