YOU SAID:
the cat stabbed my eye with a straw
INTO JAPANESE
猫はわらで私の目を刺した
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The cat stabbed me in the eye with straw.
INTO JAPANESE
猫は私の目をわらで刺した。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The cat stabbed me in the eye with straw.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.