YOU SAID:
the bat batted the bat by batting itself
INTO JAPANESE
バットは自らバッティングしてバットを打った
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The bat batted by himself and hit the bat
INTO JAPANESE
打者は自分で打ってバットに当たった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The batter hit the bat by hitting himself
INTO JAPANESE
打者は自分自身を打ってバットを打った
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The batter hit himself and hit the bat
INTO JAPANESE
打者は自ら打ってバットに当たった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The batter struck himself and hit the bat
INTO JAPANESE
打者は自ら打ってバットに当たった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The batter struck himself and hit the bat
That didn't even make that much sense in English.