YOU SAID:

Rudy has five apples because he already had the five to begin with.

INTO JAPANESE

ルディがリンゴを5個持っているのは、最初から5個のリンゴをすでに持っていたからです。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Rudy has 5 apples because he already had 5 apples from the beginning.

INTO JAPANESE

ルディは最初からすでに5つのリンゴを持っていたので、5つのリンゴを持っています。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Rudy already had five apples from the beginning, so he has five apples.

INTO JAPANESE

ルディは最初からすでに5つのリンゴを持っていたので、彼は5つのリンゴを持っています。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Rudy already had five apples from the beginning, so he has five apples.