YOU SAID:
pickles should live in carrots
INTO JAPANESE
ピクルスはニンジンに入っているはずだ
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The pickles should be in the carrot.
INTO JAPANESE
ピクルスはニンジンの中に入っているはずです。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
The pickles should be in the carrot.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.