YOU SAID:
oh no my sandwich ate the cat again
INTO JAPANESE
ああ、私のサンドイッチは再び猫を食べた
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Oh my sandwich ate the cat again
INTO JAPANESE
ああ私のサンドイッチは再び猫を食べました
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Oh my sandwich ate the cat again
That didn't even make that much sense in English.