YOU SAID:
My love for you was too much.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたのため私の愛は、あまりだった。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
My love for you was not much.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたへの私の愛はあまりありませんでした。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
My love for you was not much.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.