YOU SAID:

Lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink

INTO JAPANESE

水に馬を導くが、飲むことはできません。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

You cannot lead the horse to water, but drink.

INTO JAPANESE

水、ドリンクに馬を導くことはできません。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

You cannot lead the horse to water and drink.

INTO JAPANESE

水や飲み物に馬を導くことはできません。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

You cannot lead the horse to water and drink.