YOU SAID:

Jason should have lived and Piper should have died

INTO JAPANESE

ジェイソンは生きるべきだったパイパーは死ぬべきだった

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Jason should have lived. Piper should have died.

INTO JAPANESE

ジェイソンは生きていたはずだ。パイパーは死ぬべきだった

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Jason must have been alive. Piper should have died.

INTO JAPANESE

ジェイソンは生きていたに違いない。パイパーは死ぬべきだった

BACK INTO ENGLISH

Jason must have been alive. Piper should have died.