YOU SAID:
If that cat is orange, what color is that one?
INTO JAPANESE
その猫がオレンジ色なら、その猫は何色ですか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
If the cat is orange, what color is the cat?
INTO JAPANESE
猫がオレンジ色の場合、猫は何色ですか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
If your cat is orange, what color is your cat?
INTO JAPANESE
あなたの猫がオレンジ色の場合、あなたの猫は何色ですか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
If your cat is orange, what color is your cat?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.