YOU SAID:
I wish my crush knew I liked her and dated me
INTO JAPANESE
彼女が好きで付き合っているのを知っていればいいのに
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I wish I knew you liked her and you were dating her.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたが彼女を好きだと知っていて、彼女と付き合っていればよかったのに。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I wish I knew you liked her and you were dating her.
Come on, you can do better than that.