YOU SAID:
I wish I wasn't wishing to wish wishes anymore.
INTO JAPANESE
もう願いを望んでいなかったらよかったのに。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I wish I hadn't wanted a wish anymore.
INTO JAPANESE
もう願いが欲しくなかったらよかったのに。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I wish I didn't want a wish anymore.
INTO JAPANESE
もう願いが欲しくなかったらいいのに。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I wish I didn't want a wish anymore.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.