YOU SAID:
I was like no and she was like yeah
INTO JAPANESE
私は「いいえ」で、彼女は「はい」のようでした
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I was like no and she was like yes
INTO JAPANESE
私はノー、彼女はイエス
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I said no, she said yes
INTO JAPANESE
私はノーと言った、彼女はイエスと言った
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I said no, she said yes
That didn't even make that much sense in English.