YOU SAID:
I thought I held your hand, but that wasn’t you, was it?
INTO JAPANESE
君の手を握ったと思ったが、君じゃないよな?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I thought I held your hand, but it wasn't you, was it?
INTO JAPANESE
手を握ったと思ったが君じゃないんだな?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I thought you held my hand, but it wasn't you, was it?
INTO JAPANESE
私の手を握ったと思ってたけど、あなたじゃないわよね?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I thought you held my hand, but it wasn't you, was it?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.