YOU SAID:

I really like it when you go to the store to get bread but realy it was a cat.

INTO JAPANESE

お店にパンを買いに行くと本当に好きですが、本当に猫でした。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I really like it when I go to the store to buy bread, but I really liked it.

INTO JAPANESE

パンを買いに店に行くときは本当に好きですが、本当に好きでした。

BACK INTO ENGLISH

I really like it when I go to the store to buy bread, but I really liked it.