YOU SAID:
I love when you stab me
INTO JAPANESE
私はあなたが私を刺すのが大好きです
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I love it when you stab me.
INTO JAPANESE
あなたが私を刺すのが好きなの
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I like it when you stab me.
INTO JAPANESE
俺を刺すのが好きだ
BACK INTO ENGLISH
He likes to stab me.
INTO JAPANESE
彼は私を刺すのが好きだ。
BACK INTO ENGLISH
He likes to stab me.
That didn't even make that much sense in English.