YOU SAID:
i ate my cat... my sister ate my wet toes
INTO JAPANESE
私は猫を食べました...私の妹は私のつま先を食べました
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I ate a cat... my sister ate my toes
INTO JAPANESE
私は猫を食べた...私の妹はつま先を食べた
BACK INTO ENGLISH
I ate a cat... my sister ate my toes
That didn't even make that much sense in English.