YOU SAID:
her pinky toe ate the other carrot stick
INTO JAPANESE
彼女のピンキーなつま先が他のニンジン棒を食べた
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Her pinky toe ate another carrot stick
INTO JAPANESE
彼女のピンキーなつま先が別のニンジン棒を食べた
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Her pinky toe ate another carrot stick
That didn't even make that much sense in English.