YOU SAID:
Everyone should give me a puppy right now!
INTO JAPANESE
誰もが今すぐ子犬をくれ!
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Everyone give me a puppy now!
INTO JAPANESE
誰もが子犬をくれました!
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Everyone gave me a puppy!
INTO JAPANESE
みんな子犬をくれました!
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Everyone gave me a puppy!
That didn't even make that much sense in English.