YOU SAID:
Can you believe that guy said that to me?
INTO JAPANESE
あの男が私にそう言ったなんて信じられない?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Can you believe that guy told me that?
INTO JAPANESE
信じられるか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Can you believe that?
INTO JAPANESE
あなたはそれを信じられますか?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Can you believe that?
Come on, you can do better than that.