YOU SAID:
But wait, what if he didn't solidify underground? What if he was erupted out of a volcano?
INTO JAPANESE
そうじゃなかったとしたら?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
What if it were not so?
INTO JAPANESE
もし そうだとしたら?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
What if it were?
INTO JAPANESE
もし そうだとしたら?
BACK INTO ENGLISH
What if it were?
That didn't even make that much sense in English.