YOU SAID:
A Finger was in my food
INTO JAPANESE
指が私の食べ物の中にあった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Finger was in my food
INTO JAPANESE
指が私の食べ物にあった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Finger was on my food
INTO JAPANESE
指が私の食べ物にあった
BACK INTO ENGLISH
Finger was on my food
That didn't even make that much sense in English.